How not to become a princess and a pea, or Which mattress is better - spring or springless
Calm, sound sleep is the key to good health. It is important for your own health to take care of the condition of your bed and, first of all, your mattress. Which mattress is better: spring or springless - this is the question many of those who go shopping in a specialized store ask themselves. Pros and cons of spring mattresses, what are good orthopedic variations, what is a miracle mattress without a spring block. As always, only in our online magazine HomeMyНome.ru you will find the most useful advice on choosing household utensils and appliances. In addition, this is the only place where you can get your bearings in advance on the price, as well as read the reviews of those who have already made their choice.
You use a mattress every day, so it is very important to choose it correctly
The content of the article [Hide]
- 1 Spring mattresses and their types
- 2 Pros and cons of spring mattresses
- 3 What are mattresses without a spring block
- 4 Pros and cons of springless mattresses
- 5 Ease of use: which mattress is better - spring or springless
- 6 Orthopedic properties: what to choose
- 7 Which mattress will last longer
- 8 Matching the mattress and the person's weight
- 9 Rating of manufacturers of orthopedic mattresses
- 10 Price table for the top-rated models
- 11 Video review of a specialist: which mattress is better to choose
- 12 Customer reviews: which is better - a spring or springless mattress
- 13 Conclusion
Spring mattresses and their types
In the 18th century, spring mattresses replaced the classic wadded mattresses and down feather beds. This fashionable innovation quickly swept Europe, and to this day, box springs for beds do not give up their positions and are always popular.
The design of spring models is constantly updated with new technical solutions to ensure comfortable conditions for sleep and rest
Spring featherbeds can be roughly divided into two types: with dependent and independent springs. Let's consider them in more detail.
Mattresses with dependent springs
The spring block of such a berth includes about a hundred springs per 1 m². Each of the springs is elastic and stiff.They are connected to each other, so if you press on the mattress in one place, it will bend over a larger area. The dependent design is considered to be of economy class and does not have good orthopedic properties.
Block device - "bonnel"
The spring blocks themselves are called "bonnel". Each element in such a structure is bonded to the neighboring one. Due to this connection, the supporting effect is reduced. That is, the product bends over the entire area of the body, not taking into account its bends. If you study the reviews of the Bonnel spring blocks, it becomes clear that buyers are attracted primarily by the relatively low cost of the product. The quality is called "acceptable".
Pocket springs mattresses
Independent springs in a mattress - what are they, and why are they called pocket springs? First of all, let us note that the number of springs per 1 m² of the product is several times higher than in the “bonnel” block. And, most importantly, they are not fastened together. Each spring independently reacts to the load, that is, every bend of your body will be supported in such a feather bed. A quality product contains at least 1,000 springs per 1 m². And they are called pocket because each spring is located in its own case-pocket.
The pockets are interconnected, but this fact does not affect the operation of the entire system as a whole.
According to reviews, the advantage of a mattress with independent springs is its noiselessness. In a quality product from 500 springs per 1 m².
Spring mattresses for children and teenagers
Let's make a reservation right away that, in principle, a spring mattress is not the best idea for children's room... Any orthopedist will tell you about this. But not every family can afford an expensive specialty model. On sale you will find children's duvets with a small number of springs - only about 100 per 1 m². Such models cannot guarantee high-quality support for the child's back. If the choice fell on a children's spring mattress, pick up models that are stiffer, on a wooden or steel frame.
Such a sleeping place does not bend like a hammock, and the child does not roll out of bed in a dream
For a schoolchild or teenager, it is better to choose a model with pocket springs and a density of 300-400 pieces per 1 m². A lower density is not suitable for a child.
Pros and cons of spring mattresses
In order to find an answer to the question of which mattress is better to buy, consider the advantages and disadvantages of spring products:
| pros | Minuses |
|---|---|
| The cost of models with dependent springs is relatively low. Almost every family can afford such a sleeping place. | Mattresses react sharply to instant stress. If your children jumped on the bed, it is possible that one of the springs will hit your side at night. |
| Mattresses with independent springs support the spine well. | |
| The products are practically silent, which guarantees comfortable sleeping conditions. | |
| Quality products, selected taking into account the weight of a person, will last a long time. | |
| Spring models are subject to repair. If you have a middle ground, there are craftsmen who will restore the state of the sleeping place for a small fee. |
What are mattresses without a spring block
Orthopedists recommend using models without springs. They support the back through a combination of different fillers and can have three degrees of rigidity. Let's see how sleeping places differ with the most popular fillers.
Latex
Latex mattresses have appeared in our everyday life relatively recently.Previously, latex was only used as a top coat in spring models. Now he has completely replaced the springs.What's Attractive About Latex? It belongs to the category of hypoallergenic materials, so latex mattresses are indicated for everyone who suffers from constant and seasonal allergies.
Such a product will never start microscopic dust mites or harmful bacteria.
It does not emit any toxic substances and provides extraordinary comfort. But all these benefits apply only to high quality natural latex. Cheap counterparts stamped in China may be harmful rather than beneficial.
The firmness of latex mattresses can be different, depending on the wishes of the buyer and manufacturing technology. In reviews of latex models, there are dissatisfied statements that a body imprint remains on the sleeping place, but not only such products suffer from this.
On the spring mattress, "dips" and irregularities will appear over time
Residents of the southern regions will feel a significant lack of latex. Indeed, sleeping on latex in hot weather or simply in an apartment that is too warm is not very pleasant. Modern manufacturers have taken this fact into account, and now it is easy to find models with self-ventilation on sale. Another disadvantage of latex is its weight. These models are very heavy and difficult to move alone. All of these disadvantages are more than offset by the advantages of natural material. It relieves the accumulated tension from the muscles of the back, shoulders and hips, relieves pain in the spine and joints.
Such mattresses are an indispensable thing for the formation of correct posture.
The durability of the product should also be noted. The quality guarantee is a decade and a half. All this time the latex mattress will delight you with its comfort.
Polyurethane foam
Polyurethane foam products attract buyers with their price. Indeed, the cost of foam rubber models is low, and the quality of modern material fully meets the strict requirements of hygiene. These products, thanks to the manufacturing technology, contain 90% air. Why are there more expensive and cheaper polyurethane foam mattresses? It all depends on the structure of the product.
To save money, some manufacturers glue several layers of foam rubber together. If the reservoir is monolithic, it will cost more
Food for Thought: Fierce opponents of PPU argue that this material can be harmful to health due to its petroleum hydrocarbon content. Indeed, when ignited, these substances release toxic compounds, but in the natural state, a high-quality material is stable and safe.
Which mattress is best for a child's room: spring mattress or polyurethane foam? Keep in mind that polyurethane foam is not the best material for a baby bed. It does not provide adequate support for the spine.
Long-term use of such a berth can lead to curvature of the back and scoliosis.
Foam products are very elastic and resilient, they can support heavy people without visible consequences. If people with different weights sleep on a double polyurethane foam mattress, this will not affect its condition in any way. Polyurethane foam retains its shape for a long time - this is another argument in its favor. It is lightweight and breathable. The disadvantage of this product is its ability to absorb moisture and odors.
Coconut fiber
The internet is replete with negative reviews of coconut filler. It is believed that the fibers of this fruit vaporize formaldehyde compounds and can lead to serious health problems, especially in children. Do not rush to believe everything that is written. In fact, the natural material does not emit any toxins.
Basically, coira is a straw that can't harm anyone.
But the latex glue that holds these fibers together can actually release formaldehyde.Responsible manufacturers are moving away from this filler formation method. They do not hold the fibers together with artificial latex, but press them and pierce them with special needles. Such fillers are absolutely safe, but, unfortunately, less durable.
Mattresses with coconut filling, coir, are recommended for people with backbone diseases. The well-known healer Dikul in our country advises using just such products. The service life of such a bed is up to 20 years.
Coir is resistant to moisture, odors and does not cause an allergic reaction
Lice and bugs do not settle in coconut fiber, the material does not rot. The softness of the mattress depends on the thickness of the coconut layer.
Other types of fillers
For flooring on top of the springs, thick wool felt or cotton wool is used. Special thermal insulation qualities sheep wool is valued. In addition to the listed natural materials, manufacturers use holofiber for filling feather beds - a soft polyester fiber material that is resistant to moisture and odors. In order to summarize all the positive qualities of different fillers, mattress manufacturers use multilayer products that include natural latex, coir and polyurethane foam.
Such complex designs are valued for their excellent orthopedic properties and long service life.
Pros and cons of springless mattresses
Filled mattresses have some disadvantages and even more advantages. Consider them:
| pros | Minuses |
|---|---|
| Products with a hard filler have good orthopedic properties. | The price of quality springless mattresses is quite high, especially if combined layers are used. |
| Latex products are suitable for those who prefer a soft bed. | Such products are limited in human weight - up to 140 kilograms. Under greater load, they quickly deform. |
| Springless models are silent and do not transmit vibrations to a person sleeping next to them. | |
| Such products can be transported by rolling. | Some types of products have an impressive weight. |
| In feather beds with synthetic filling insects do not start, they do not absorb odors. |
If you really choose the type of filler - give preference to hypoallergenic natural materials.
Ease of use: which mattress is better - spring or springless
But if you think about which mattress is better and more comfortable - with or without springs, then it turns out that there is a direct connection in sensations from different types of berths and a person's age. For young people, it is better to choose rigid products that keep their shape well. Mattresses for people with back pain are selected according to the same principle. So models with pocket springs or coconut filling are more suitable for them.
Latex mattress fillers are the best feather bed option for seniors. On such a bed, they will feel much more comfortable.
Orthopedic properties: what to choose
Do not forget that the sleeping place must correspond to the height and weight of the person. It should be at least 20 cm higher than the height and be no more than 80 cm. But as for orthopedic qualities, a lot depends on the preferences and state of health of the owner. Children need bed with good orthopedic support - these can be models with pocket springs, coconut filling, or quality mattresses with combined layers. Adults should prefer models with a large number of springs. In this regard, latex and polyurethane foam are behind other options.
Before purchasing a rather expensive product, do not hesitate to seek advice from an orthopedist
Which mattress will last longer
The duration of the operation of the berth depends not only on the quality of the material. It is clear that cheap models made of materials that do not meet high quality standards will not last long. If the manufacturer has saved on the number of springs or used a low-quality coil, the product will quickly fail.But the operating conditions are no less important.
Spring mattresses do not withstand mechanical loads poorly, despite this, children often use them as a trampoline
If moisture periodically gets on the feather bed, the springs in it will quickly rust and collapse. On average, it is believed that a bed with a spring device should retain its characteristics for 10 years. Springless models can not be changed for 15 years.
Matching the mattress and the person's weight
How important is this factor? If a person's weight is within the average, that is, does not exceed 110 kg, he can choose any model, not paying much attention to the technical characteristics, but trusting only his own preferences. People weighing over 110 kg need to pay attention to springless products. They evenly distribute the load and support all body curves well.
If you give preference to springs, it is possible that they will not cope with the load and deform unevenly, forming dents that will prevent you from taking a comfortable sleeping position
Rating of manufacturers of orthopedic mattresses
The rating of the best products is made by the buyers themselves. Before purchasing a mattress, read user reviews. Stores respecting their customers do not hide negative feedback. And they can give you a complete picture of the quality and usability of the mattress. We have already noted that there is no unambiguous answer to the question of which mattress is better - spring or springless. It all depends on your requirements, preferences and financial capabilities. But you can find the answer to the question of which company is better to buy a mattress. We analyzed the rating of products for you according to Yandex.Market data, and this is what happened:
5th place - "Comfort Line"
The "Comfort Line Roll Classic" firm got into the rating of the best manufacturers for the high assessment of the springless models. They are comfortable and have a long service life. The manufacturer uses different types of fillers. The only nuance that users note is the smell that is present in the first months after buying a mattress.
Comfort Line Roll Classic
4th place - "Ormatek"
The domestic manufacturer Ormatek uses the most advanced technologies borrowed from developers from the USA and Europe. Factories "Ormatek" produce spring and springless products. Particular attention is paid to the possibility of air exchange and the hygiene of the mattresses.
Mattress Ormatek Flex Strong
3rd place - "Beautyson"
Combined products made of latex and pocket springs became the leaders of this manufacturer. The absence of toxic glue and the high quality of the material make Beautyson mattresses very popular in our market. There are many positive reviews about the products of this company from people with great weight.
Mattress Beautyson Baby Elite
2nd place - "Ascona"
This brand is heard by almost everyone. Ascona offers a wide selection of not only spring beds, but also orthopedic pillows. Many users ask which mattresses are better - "Ascona" or "Ormatek"? Both of these manufacturers guarantee high quality products, but perhaps Ascona stands out for its special patented anti-deformation system, which keeps the bed in its original condition for a long time.
Mattress IMPRESSION PLUS
1st place - "Magniflex"
Magniflex won this rating in a tough fight with Ascona, but it was this manufacturer that received the majority of Yandex Market visitors. The most comfortable mattresses are produced in Italy. They are distinguished by a special "memory" system - the surface of the berth fixes a position convenient for you. All mattresses have two working sides - for the cool and hot seasons, it is very convenient. The price for such models is rather big, but believe me, they are worth it.
Mattress Magniflex Stretching 9
Price table for the top-rated models
So that you have an idea of the cost of products from the listed manufacturers, we suggest that you familiarize yourself with the prices for children's and double models:
| Photo | Model | Manufacturer | Cost, rub. |
|---|---|---|---|
 | Comfort Line Baby Eco-Hard TFK (children) | Comfort Line | 4025 |
 | Comfort Line Eco Slim TFK | Comfort Line | 7396 |
 | Ormatek Kids Dream (for children) | "Ormatek" | 4990 |
 | Ormatek Optima Classic EVS420 | "Ormatek" | 13840 |
 | Beautyson Baby Queen (children) | Beautyson | 4065 |
 | Beautyson Hit Anatomic S1200 | Beautyson | 24140 |
 | Ascona Baby Flex Jump (for children) | "Ascona" | 2095 |
 | Ascona Balance Status | "Ascona" | 9616 |
 | Magniflex Merino (Merinos) (children) | Magniflex | 11900 |
 | Magniflex Merino | Magniflex | 36500 |
Related article:
Video review of a specialist: which mattress is better to choose
We bring to your attention an overview and opinion of professionals on choosing the best bed:
Customer reviews: which is better - a spring or springless mattress
If we analyze the controversy on this issue in numerous forums, we can say that the scales are tilted towards combined spring models. Here are some great testimonials that can give you an idea of the heart of the matter:
Conclusion
Buying a bed in a hurry is unlikely to benefit you. A mattress is an item that you will use every day. Weigh carefully all the pros and cons and choose the best option following our recommendations and feedback from real buyers.
Better yet, having decided on some models, go to the salon with the second half and, absolutely not being shy, lie down on the demonstration exhibits
This is the only way you can choose the best feather bed, and you are guaranteed not to feel like a princess and a pea every morning.
Write in the comments what you think on this issue and share your experience!
Loading... See also:
TV stand in modern style: photo, equipment, selection rules 
Taking care of your back, or How to choose a mattress for a double bed 
How to choose a corner wardrobe in the bedroom - the technology of the correct acquisition of furniture from "A" to "Z" 
Tropical atmosphere in the home and garden: artificial rattan furniture 
Convenient, functional, comfortable: bed with storage boxes 
Choosing a wonderful pillow for sleep and relaxation by filler - which of the materials is better
